|
|
Resources
divine/Faxon/RoweCom Information
MLA has set up this site to help members keep abreast of the divine/Faxon/RoweCom
situation. As we receive information, we will post it to the site and
keep you updated through MLA-FOCUS. Site last updated June 25, 2003.
How You Can Keep Informed
- Visit this site for updates. As we receive additional
information, we will post it to this site and keep you updated via MLA-FOCUS.
- Sign up on liblicense-l@lists.yale.edu, a discussion
list about licensing issues. This is a good source for the most up-to-date
news releases about the Faxon/RoweCom issue. Visit the Liblicense-L
Website to sign up, or visit the searchable Liblicense-L
archive for recent postings.
- The ad hoc creditors committee examining this issue
will be posting committee minutes at groups.yahoo.com/group/rowecomcreditors/
(registration is required; you must be a RoweCom customer or publisher).
This group will also allow you to post comments and questions to the
group. You can also contact the committee via email,
adhoccommittee@nyc.rr.com.
- Visit the articles listed below for
an overview of this issue in the news.
Are You Affected? Contact Us!
Are you affected by this situation? If so, please email
Carla J. Funk,
CAE, funk@mlahq.org, to let us know what impact this is having on your
ability to serve your users.
Formation of Ad Hoc Committee
On December 20, 2002, an ad hoc committee (the "Committee")
was formed in order to, among other things, perform investigations and
analyses of the operations and financial condition of RoweCom, Inc. ("RoweCom)
and its parent corporation, Divine, Inc. ("Divine"), initiate
negotiations with RoweCom and Divine, and take such other actions that
the Committee may determine are in the best interests of its constituency.
Suzanne Grefsheim, National Institutes of Health, an MLA member and former
MLA officer, is on this small ad hoc group of five publishers and five
librarians.
Recent Press Releases, Communications, and Documents
(reverse chronological order)
- EBSCO
Acquisition of RoweCom Timeline (cited 6/24/2003)

- EBSCO
Finalizes Acquisitions of RoweCom U.S.A., Australia and Canada
6/4/2003 (online press release, cited 6/24/2003)

- EBSCO
Finalizes Acquisition of RoweCom's European Operations 6/4/2003
(online press release, cited 6/24/2003)

- U.S.
Bankruptcy Court Approves EBSCO's Purchase of RoweCom U.S.A.
4/11/2003 (online press release, cited 4/21/2003)
- Updated list of participating publishers is
periodically posted on the kccllc.net
Website (look mid-page; latest list dated 6/20/2003,
)
- divine,
inc. bankruptcy documents (Trumbull Services
Bankruptcy Website; cited 4/21/2003)
- FAQ for RoweCom Prepaid Order Agreement. (available
via Website or
) 3/11/2003.
- EBSCO
Industries, Inc. Announces Execution of Definitive Agreements for the
Purchase of RoweCom Australia Pty Ltd. 3/6/2003 (online press
release, cited 3/11/2003).
- EBSCO
Industries, Inc. Announces Execution of Definitive Agreements for the
Purchase of RoweCom, Inc. U.S.A. (press
release, 3/5/2003,
).
- United
State Bankruptcy Court Supplemental Order Regarding Prepaid Order Package
and Publisher "Gracing". 3/4/2003
- Firm representing the Official Committee of Unsecured
Creditors email to rowecomcreditors
Yahoo group re. state of court actions 3/5/2003 (copy of email; TXT,
4KB).
- divine,
inc. Receives Notice of Nasdaq Delisting 3/4/2003 (online press
release, cited 3/5/2003).
- Creditors
Meeting Notice, to be held February 27, 2003.
.
For futher information, visit the Website of Kurtzman
Carson Consultants (www.kccllc.net/rowecom) for other court and
bankruptcy documents.
- divine,
inc. to File Voluntary Petition to Reorganize under Chapter 11 Today
2/25/2003 (online press release cited 2/28/2003)
- Rowecom
Australia Website (cited 2/28/2003)
- divine
Exploring Strategic Options [possible bankruptcy or sale preliminaries]
2/18/2003 (online press release cited 2/19/2003)
- divine
Announces Sale of RoweComs Operations in France, the United Kingdom
and Spain to EBSCO Industries 2/6/2003 (online press release,
cited 2/19/2003)
- EBSCO
on Schedule in Acquiring RoweCom Operations Worldwide
2/6/2003 (online press release, cited 2/11/2003)
- EBSCO
Industries, Inc. Announces Execution of Definitive Agreements for the
Purchase of European Operations of RoweCom, 2/4/2003 (online
press release, cited 2/11/2003)
- RoweCom
Complaint v Divine, Inc.: "Rowecom brings this action for
damages and to recover over $73.7 million which Defendant divine, inc.
("divine") has fraudulently and wrongfully transferred from
RoweCom to itself, within the 12 months prior to the commencement of
RoweCom's chapter 11 bankruptcy case on January 27, 2003."
- RoweCom
Backruptcy Petition, including forty
largest unsecured creditors, 1/27/2003.
- Swets
Blackwell withdraws bid for divine/RoweCom, 1/24/2003 (online
press release, cited 1/27/2003)
- AMA email to
JAMA subscribers in response to MLA letter, 1/23/2003 (text
file, 1KB)
- MLA letter
to AMA on behalf of members regarding JAMA subscriptions, 1/20/2003
(Text file, 3KB)
- RoweCom
due diligence press release, 1/8/2003 (link to Liblicense-L
archives)
- RoweCom press release, 12/20/2002 (Available
as
,
or ).
- divine,
Inc. press release, 12/20/2002, including announcement that
"divine is announcing its intent to divest the content subscription
business delivered through its RoweCom, Inc. subsidiary."
Recent Articles
(reverse chronological order)
- Walker L. The
Company That Bought The Bust. Washinton Post [Internet] 2003 Jun
12. [cited 24 June 2003]. See also this
unpublished letter to the editor from Elsevier, as posted to the
rowecomcreditors Yahoo group.

- RoweCom
Sells For $7M--But It'll End Up Less. Library Journal [Internet]
2003 Apr 15. [cited 24 June 2003].

- Quist B. EBSCOs
Takeover of RoweCom Continues. Information Today [Internet] 2002
Mar 10. [cited 11 Mar 2003].
- Rose B. Divine
confident it will be cleared. Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2003 Mar
5. [cited 5 Mar 2003; free site registration may be required to view].
- Rose B. Divine
faces federal probe; Grand jury wants to determine fate of libraries'
cash. Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2003 Mar 4. [cited 5 Mar 2003;
free site registration may be required to view].
- Rose B. Divine
saga leaves some richer--in experience. Chicago Tribune [Internet]
2003 Mar 2. [cited 5 Mar 2003; free site registration may be required
to view].
- Johnsson J. Real
estate eases Divine collapse. Crain's Chicago Business [Internet]
2003 Mar 1. [cited 5 Mar 2003].
- Rose B. Divine's
parts, not its concept, lure bidder. Chicago Tribune [Internet]
2003 Feb 28. [cited 28 Feb 2003; free site registration may be required
to view].
- Wolinsky H. Divine
files Ch. 11, has suitor for units. Chicago Sun Times [Internet]
2003 Feb 26. [cited 28 Feb 2003].
- Rose B. Divine
files for Chapter 11; Highly visible tech firm cost investors millions.
Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2003 Feb 26. [cited 27 Feb 2003; free site
registration required to view].
- Rose B. Divine
considering Chapter 11; Pritzker's New World Ventures gives back funds.
Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2003 Feb 19. [cited 19 Feb 2003; free site
registration required to view].
- Rose B. Divine
wooing buyers for units; Sales would help in a bankruptcy. Chicago
Tribune [Internet] 2003 Feb 18. [cited 19 Feb 2003; free site registration
required to view].
- Rose B., Kaiser R. RoweCom
purchase haunting Divine; Buyer infected by problems it couldn't cure.
Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2003 Feb 9. [cited 19 Feb 2003; free site
registration required to view].
- Hane PJ. Divine
Debacle Rocks Industry. Information Today [Internet] 2003 Feb. [cited
20 Feb 2003].
- Kaiser R. Lawsuit:
Divine looted company; Creditors allege millions taken from RoweCom.
Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2003 Jan 29. [cited 3 Feb 2003; free site
registration required to view].
- Kaiser R. Divine
strikes deal to sell library subscription unit. Chicago Tibune [Internet]
2003 Jan 28. [cited 28 Jan 2003; free site registration required to
view].
- Wilkinson S. Divine
Debacle. Chemical and Engineering News [Internet] 2003 Jan 27. [cited
28 Jan 2003].
- Manor R, Kaiser R. New
buyer in Divine unit talks; Library-service fees negotiated. Chicago
Tribune [Internet] 2003 Jan 25. [cited 27 Jan 2003].
- Greising D. Welcome
aboard, Flip; sorry, we're out of magazines. Chicago Tribune [Internet]
2003 Jan 19. [cited 20 Jan 2003; free site registration required to
view].
- Cullen D. Is
this why Divine Inc. is screwing small dotcoms? The Register [Internet]
2003 Jan 18. [cited 27 Jan 2003].
- Manor R, Kaiser R. Divine
in talks on libraries; Dispute centers on $50 million in subscription
fees. Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2003 Jan 18. [cited 20 Jan 2003;
free site registration required to view].
- Follow
Up on Devine, Inc. Nightly Business Report (transcript) [Internet].
2003 Jan 17. [cited 23 Jan 2003].
- Manor R, Kaiser R. Divine
unit suit: Libraries may lose $50 million. Chicago Tribune [Internet]
2003 Jan 17. [cited 17 Jan 2003; free site registration required to
view].
- Beckett C. divine
intervention. UKSG Serials-e-news [Internet] 2003 Jan 14. [cited
21 Jan 2003.
- Chicago:
Today's City Of Commerce-Part 3: CEO Andrew Filipowski's divine Plan.
Nightly Business Report (transcript) [Internet] 2003 Jan 14. [cited
23 Jan 2003].
- Comment
from ASA Secretary General Rollo Turner. Liblicense-L email discussion
list [Internet] 2003 Jan 14. [cited 15 Jan 2003].
- Libraries
Calculate Fallout From divine/RoweCom/Faxon Failure. Library Journal
[Internet] 2003 Jan 13 [cited 14 Jan 2003].
- Publishers
to Fulfill Subscriptions, But For How Long? Library Journal [Internet]
2003 Jan 13 [cited 14 Jan 2003].
- Hane PJ. RoweCom
and divine Negotiate with Creditors and Potential Buyers. Information
Today [Internet] 2003 Jan 13. [cited 20 Jan 2003].
- Farrell, EF. Subscription
Service's Difficulties Could Be Costly for Libraries and Publishers.
Chronicle of Higher Education. 2003 Jan 10. [cited 13 Jan 2003; subscription
required to read).
- Ad
Hoc Committee Meets on RoweCom. Library Journal [Internet] 2003
Jan 6 [cited 14 Jan 2003].
- Divine/Faxon
creditors join forces. Crain's Chicago Business [Internet] 2003
Jan 5. [cited 14 Jan 2003].
- RoweCom/Faxon
Going Bankrupt? Library Journal [Internet] 2002 Dec 23 [cited 14
Jan 2003].
- Quint, B, Hane, PJ. divine
Library Services Financial Collapse Traps Library Subscription Budgets.
Information Today [Internet] 2002 Dec 20. [cited 10 Jan 2003].
- Rose B. Playing
the Flip Side [column]. Chicago Tribune [Internet] 2002 April 25.
[cited 19 Feb 2003; free site registration required to view].
Tips to Assist Members
You may want to consider taking these steps to help protect your library:
Payment of Amounts Due to RoweCom
Libraries clearly should not pay any invoices from RoweCom for subscriptions
that have not been fulfilled.
In addition, if your library owes money to RoweCom for past subscriptions
that have been placed, you may want to consider withholding payment.
A creditor can setoff amounts that it owes to a company against amounts
owed to it. RoweCom has stated that it will not honor most, if not all,
of its 2003 subscription agreements. This means that your library may
have (or may soon have) a breach of contract claim against RoweCom.
If your library owes money to RoweCom for unpaid subscriptions, you
might want to withhold payment so that you can offset these amounts
against your damages should the subscription agreements in fact not
be honored. You may also want to create a record of your actions by
sending a letter to RoweCom notifying it of your intent to withhold
further payments and the reason for doing so.
Joining the Ad Hoc Committee
Committees of creditors, both in and outside of bankruptcy, are a good
vehicle for obtaining information and protecting your company's claim.
The Ad Hoc Committee has retained legal counsel and financial investigators
and is probably the best source of information on RoweCom's financial
situation.
Libraries that are RoweCom customers can sign up as a member of the
Committee at groups.yahoo.com/group/rowecomcreditors.
Libraries should also continue to try to contact RoweCom at (800) 769-3266
to determine the status of any orders placed with the company.
Finding Alternative Sources
Because RoweCom has publicly announced that it will be unable to fulfill
the majority of its 2003 subscriptions, your library has reasonable
grounds for insecurity under any agreement that you may have with RoweCom.
To the extent that these agreements require your library to deal exclusively
through RoweCom, you have grounds to request assurance of performance
by RoweCom and to terminate the agreement in writing if they cannot
provide it.
Although you should consult with your legal counsel before taking action,
a request for adequate assurance must be made in writing. If RoweCom
does not respond in a satisfactory manner, your library would then be
able to terminate the agreement (depending on the contract's terms).
Proof of Claim
If RoweCom files for bankruptcy, you will likely want to prepare what's
called a "proof of claim." This document will formally establish
your library as one of RoweCom's creditors. However, you should have
sufficient notice to file such a claim once a bankruptcy proceeding
has been initiated. If you have a complicated claim, you may want to
consult with bankruptcy counsel about preparing the claim in advance
of the filing of a bankruptcy proceeding.
|
|